Riddles Puzzle
Five Riddles Where the Answer Feels Obvious Afterwards
A good riddle only works if the answer is undeniable once you hear it. Five that pass that test, with full explanations for each one.
A riddle is a small machine with one moving part. It works by describing something accurately while deliberately steering you towards the wrong category of thing, and the pleasure comes entirely from the moment the category flips.
Which is why a bad riddle is so annoying. If the answer requires information you could not have had, or if two answers fit equally well, the machine does not click — it just stops.
The five below all pass the test. Read them, commit to an answer, and then open the reveal.
The riddles
One. I am tall when I am young, and I grow shorter as I get older. What am I?
Two. I appear once in a minute, twice in a moment, and never in a thousand years. What am I?
Three. The more you take, the more you leave behind. What are they?
Four. The more of it you take away, the bigger it gets. What is it?
Five. It belongs to you, but other people use it far more than you do. What is it?
Why the second one catches people
Riddle two is the one that divides a room, because it can be read in two completely different ways.
Most people hear it as a riddle about time, and start hunting for something that happens once a minute and twice a moment, which is impossible. The riddle is not about time at all: it is about the words themselves, and the moment you make that switch the answer is immediate.
That flip — from the thing being described to the word describing it — is one of the oldest devices in riddling, and it turns up in collections going back centuries.
Open the reveal below for all five answers and the reasoning behind each.
Reveal the answer
Answer 1. A candle · 2. The letter M · 3. Footsteps · 4. A hole · 5. Your name
1. A candle: it grows shorter the longer it burns, and it is at its tallest when new. 2. The letter M: it appears once in the word minute, twice in moment, and not at all in a thousand years. 3. Footsteps: the more you take, the more you leave behind you. 4. A hole: removing material from it makes it larger, not smaller. 5. Your name: it belongs to you, but other people use it far more often than you do.
Read next
Logic Puzzle Four Clues, One Queue: Can You Work Out the Order?
A short ordering puzzle with a single provable answer. Every clue is needed, and a solver checks that only one arrangement fits before it is published.
Rebus Can You Read This Word Picture? The Layout Is the Clue
A rebus puzzle where the arrangement of the words matters more than the words themselves, drawn as real type so nothing is ambiguous.
Puzzle This Matchstick Equation Is Wrong. Move One Stick to Fix It
A matchstick puzzle with exactly one solution, found by searching every legal single-stick move before publication. Ambiguous matchstick puzzles are the most common broken puzzle online.